Duplicate NARs

When identified, duplicate NARs should be reported for deletion to NACO through the following workflow:

  1. Decide which NAR should be retained.

  2. Consolidate the information from both records onto the NAR to be kept. This may include 670s with additional data or other fields not present in the record to be retained. (For examples, please see the relevant NACO training slides attached below) Additional updates to the retained record can be made at this time as well (upgrade to RDA, additional fields, etc.)

  3. Add the updated record to the NACO JIRA board as usual.

  4. After the updated record had been submitted to the NAF, email NACO@loc.gov to have them delete the duplicate record. Sample email:

SUBJECT: Duplicate NAR for deletion

BODY: Please delete this duplicate NAR:

Centro Cristiano de Reflexión y Diálogo (Cuba)
010 = no2006096025

in favor of this existing NAR:

Centro Cristiano de Reflexión y Diálogo (Cárdenas, Cuba)
010: no2002045205

If additional BFM is required, include that in the email as well:

which means these records needs BFM in loc.gov :
010= 45019179

and

010= 38014537

 

From Guidelines for reporting NACO BFM:

3. Duplicate name heading reporting

OCLC also sends to LC an error report identifying duplicate headings in the authority database, allowing LC staff to resolve conflicts and to maintain affected bibliographic records. As of result, exact duplicates do not need to be reported to LC. However, logical duplicates for the same entity that use different 1XX forms do still need to be reported to LC.

TABLE 3: DUPLICATES

TABLE 3: DUPLICATES

Non-Reportable: Duplicate NARs for same entity with identical 100 headings

nr 00018986

Existing heading

100 1 $a Iyer, Subramaniam

no 00046934

Duplicate for same entity with identical heading to be deleted, with no need for BFM

100 1 $a Iyer, Subramaniam

 

Reportable: Duplicate NARs for same entity with different 100 headings, even if no LC bibliographic records are affected. Please note if BFM is needed.

nr 9218404

Existing heading

100 1 $a Day, William Howard, $d -1900

nr 9810714

Duplicate NAR with different heading reported to be deleted, and BFM reported as needed

100 1 $a Day, William, $d -1900