Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

Create from Template
spaceKeyDSPAC
blueprintModuleCompleteKeycom.atlassian.confluence.plugins.confluence-software-blueprints:requirements-blueprint
templateNamecom.atlassian.confluence.plugins.confluence-software-blueprints:requirements-blueprint
buttonLabelAdd Product requirements

...

Product Requirements Matrix

Requirements matrix column guide:
'Already available in DSpace'- says whether or not a feature is available through turnkey DSpace.
'Back end or front end'- 'back end' features would be implemented through DSpace, 'front end' either through DSpace's front end or a skin.
'Systems possible'- indicates which systems could support the feature 
'Relationship to DSpace; Notes/Decisions'- describes per feature the relationship between DSpace and a hypothetical skin.  It also contains relevant notes
Core RequirementSummary Who must execute it? 

Priority level: Must have/Should have/Could have/Won't have

Back end or front end featureMetadata or Services group?  Systems possible Already available in DSpace?Relationship to DSpace; Notes/DecisionsTicketsReference links

Standard repository features- front end

Searching, Facets, thumbnails, search results interface, item interface, customizable header footer and landing page

Devs

or

Gabe/Chin

Must HaveFrontS

Blacklight

DSpace custom

DSpace standard

Yes


Primary Search- full text indexingsearch full text via PDF OCRDevsShould haveFrontS
Yes
Jira Legacy
serverSystem JIRA
serverId72190e5c-ce35-3f39-b915-64292d694deb
keyDSPAC-86

How to set up full text indexing in DSpace: https://wiki.duraspace.org/display/DSPACE/Configure+full+text+indexing


Primary Search- metadata indexingSearch item metadataDevsMust haveFrontS
Yes


Advanced search- functionally identical to DSpace

--Applied facets also function as filters

--DSpace lets you select which fields are searchable via advanced search.  

DevsMust haveFrontS
Yes

Advanced search with facets applied: http://155.247.166.104:8080/xmlui/discover?filtertype_0=subject&filtertype_1=title&filter_relational_operator_1=equals&filter_relational_operator_0=equals&filter_1=&filter_0=%7CTemple+University&filtertype=subject&filter_relational_operator=equals&filter=explicit

Instructions for customizing which DSpace fields https://wiki.duraspace.org/display/DSPACE/Modify+search+fields

Advanced search- collating fieldsCombining two fields separated on the back end for practical reasons into a single field in the advanced search UIDevs

S: Should have

M: Should have

Back

M

S

DSpace back end NoDefinitely a developer task
See: http://kim-shepherd.blogspot.com/2010/11/discovering-discovery-dspace-solr-tips.html
Customizable header and footer- configurable by devsOne time configuration.  It should remain relatively static, but might need to be updated occasionalDevsMust haveFrontS
Sort of: requires lightweight code changes


Customizable header and footer- configurable by site adminWould be configurable by site admins via a CMSDevsCould haveFrontS
No


Item display page- image viewer- other formatsWhen appropriate, all visual items would display at full size in an image viewer.  DevsCould haveFrontS
NoThis would exceed DSpace's current capabilities

Item display page- image viewer- PDF specificWhen appropriate, PDFs would display at full size in an image viewer.  
Should have
S
NoThis would exceed DSpace's current capabilities

Item display page- just thumbnails + downloadsA thumbnail leading to a download link would appear on each item pageDevsMust haveFrontS
YesThis would equal DSpace's out-of-the-box functionality

Responsive site design
DevsShould have
S
Yes, via Mirage2 theme


DOIs- autogenerationDOI generated automatically when an item is created.  Each record will be assigned a DOI, while individual files and collections/communities will not.  Gabe/Chin

S: Must have 

M: Must have

Back

S

M

DSpace back endYesWe'd be using the Datacite procedure described on this page.  Versioning would not be used, so I believe the metadata would not be sent back to Datacite if updated.    
Out of the box DOI integration:  https://wiki.duraspace.org/display/DSDOC6x/DOI+Digital+Object+Identifier
Customize Facets for displayDecide which fields are faceted, control facet order.  This doesn't have to be doable by non-devs, and the fields used as facets would be decided prior to any development work.  This list of fields would not change.  Gabe/ChinMust haveFrontS

Blacklight

DSpace custom

Yes
Jira Legacy
serverSystem JIRA
serverId72190e5c-ce35-3f39-b915-64292d694deb
keyDSPAC-71

Procedure: https://wiki.duraspace.org/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=30218817


Citation generationAutomatic Citation generation, either via DSpace's native features or some sort of external plugin that functions through the interfaceDevsShould have UnclearS

Blacklight

DSpace custom

DSpace standard

No

What the services group has requested is the sort of functionality offered by EBSCO or most equivalent systems.  Click on 'cite' on this page to see an example.  

DSpace doesn't offer out-of-the-box citation generation.  They suggest several ways to implement a java-based solution on this page.  

Jira Legacy
serverSystem JIRA
serverId72190e5c-ce35-3f39-b915-64292d694deb
keyDSPAC-73
https://wiki.duraspace.org/display/DSPACE/Citation+Generation
Direct Submission form- form A direct submission form for use by faculty Gabe/ChinMust haveBackSDSpace back endYes
Jira Legacy
serverSystem JIRA
serverId72190e5c-ce35-3f39-b915-64292d694deb
keyDSPAC-68

Documentation:  https://wiki.duraspace.org/display/DSDOC6x/Submission+User+Interface

Input forms customized via: https://github.com/DSpace/dspace-release/blob/master/config/input-forms.xml (The form-map maps collection handles to forms.)

Item submission process customized via this:  https://github.com/DSpace/DSpace/blob/master/dspace/config/item-submission.xml  (The process-map maps collection handles to a particular Item Submission Process.)

slide deck: https://www.slideshare.net/bramluyten/secrets-of-the-dspace-submission-form


Direct Submission form- Public access via web A way to authenticate users submitting through the form, probably via ShibbolethGabe/ChinMust haveBackSDSpace back endNo

The plan is to use Shibboleth to restrict access to the direct submission form (as in the Shibboleth Authentication section of this page).  This submission form + Elements would be the two ways external users could submit on their own to the IR.  In either case the items would enter an approval queue that would be vetted by the repo manager.  External to DSpace in some regard.  

The plan is to embargo some items via DSpace's out-of-the-box embargo functionality.  The URLs of embargoed items end with ' isAllowed=n' rather than ' isAllowed=y'

Jira Legacy
serverSystem JIRA
serverId72190e5c-ce35-3f39-b915-64292d694deb
keyDSPAC-82

https://wiki.duraspace.org/display/DSDOC6x/Authentication+Plugins

Homepage- customizable by devsCustomizable display layer, including homepage, subpage, configurable interface, customizable facets, etc.  This does not have to be configurable by the site admins, just by devs, and such pages should remain mostly static.

Devs

Gabe/Chin

Must haveFrontS

Blacklight

DSpace front end custom

DSpace front end standard

Yes, lightweight code changes
Jira Legacy
serverSystem JIRA
serverId72190e5c-ce35-3f39-b915-64292d694deb
keyDSPAC-76

'Making DSpace your own' webinar

https://www.slideshare.net/DuraSpace/42418-making-dspace-your-own-webinar-recording

Here's the custom code from the webinar

https://github.com/DSpace-Labs/DSpace-rel-demo

Homepage- customizable by repo managerupdatable on the fly through a CMS DevsCould haveFrontS




Homepage, with community landing pages.  with links to search results corresponding to DSpace communities and collections.   just search results.  
Tentative- Could have
S

Homepage: 

https://ecommons.cornell.edu/

Landing page: 

https://ecommons.cornell.edu/handle/1813/52201

Homepage:

https://atmire.com/preview/

Landing Page:

https://atmire.com/preview/handle/123456789/5286




Homepage, no landing pages, just links to canned search results, no explanatory text  No landing pages for Data, ETDs, etc.
Must Have (Tentative)
S

Homepage: 

https://ecommons.cornell.edu/

Home page (mirage2): 

https://atmire.com/preview/



Theming- consistent throughout site The skin would cover all aspects of site
Should have (Tentative).  However, this depends on how seamlessly the two systems can be interlaced so it's hard to give a firm ranking.  
S




Theming- blacklight themeing for homepage and search, but other site areas are raw DSpace pages

Must have (Tentative)
S

Fully shielding DSpace would be preferable, but if visual consistency can be maintained it could be fine to switch between skinned pages and raw DSpace pages.  There are also structural concerns, for example how would the breadcrumb trail on a page like this be handled.  

Documentation portal- external to siteA place to contain our policies and advisory text 

Devs

Gabe/Chin

Must haveFrontS

Blacklight

DSpace front end custom


External to DSpace, as well as a part of the custom homepage
Jira Legacy
serverSystem JIRA
serverId72190e5c-ce35-3f39-b915-64292d694deb
keyDSPAC-77

Customize item display page- structural Ability to customize the features of each page.  For example, adjusting thumbnail size.  This would be a one time thing, done by devs.  The repo manager does not need to be able to do this on the fly through a CMS.

Devs

Gabe/Chin

Could haveFrontS

Blacklight

DSpace front end custom

DSpace front end standard


Doable out-of-the box in DSpace up until a point.  Would require dev support for more sophisticated integrations.  

Each item page would be structurally identical, and the template for these pages would only need to be implemented once, by devs.   

The desired features are:  

--Thumbnail

--View/download option.  View would open the item for viewing in a new tab as in DSpace

--Facets

Jira Legacy
serverSystem JIRA
serverId72190e5c-ce35-3f39-b915-64292d694deb
keyDSPAC-79
Thread: https://groups.google.com/forum/#!searchin/dspace-tech/orcid|sort:date/dspace-tech/f_BZETZYXiM/mavRYst_AwAJ
Item display page- Introductory page Selected fields would be highlighted and enlarged for readability
Must haveFrontS

DSpace example

Item display page-  full list of metadata fields All metadata values listed next to their dc.fieldname
Must haveFrontS

DSpace example

Visual improvements/aesthetic upgrades to the interface, including search results, item view, homepage, etc.Customizing colors, fonts, etc.  This doesn't have to be done through a CMS; it could be a one-time thing implemented by a dev that would remain static after that.  DevsMust haveFrontS

Blacklight

DSpace front end custom

DSpace front end standard





Search results interface- structuralFor example, the structure of this pageDevsCould haveFrontS

Blacklight

DSpace front end custom

DSpace front end standard


It could look and function similarly to the blacklight search interface.

Once configured by a dev it wouldn't have to be changed.



Search results interface- Metadata previewFor example, the preview fields featured on this pageDevsMust haveFrontS

Once configured by a dev it wouldn't have to be changed.

Search results interface- ThumbnailsFor example, the thumbnails featured on this pageDevsMust haveFrontS

Once configured by a dev it wouldn't have to be changed.

Search results interface- results sortingComparable to, but not necessarily identical to, DSpace'sDevsMust haveFrontS




View and download counts Analytics integrated into front end

Devs

Gabe/Chin

Must haveFrontS

Blacklight

DSpace front end custom


Configurable through Mirage2
Jira Legacy
serverSystem JIRA
serverId72190e5c-ce35-3f39-b915-64292d694deb
keyDSPAC-78

Documentation: 

https://wiki.duraspace.org/display/DSDOC6x/DSpace+Google+Analytics+Statistics


RAMP:

http://ramp.montana.edu/

Analytics (back end)Site admins can retrieve and run reports on analyticsGabe/ChinMust haveBackSDSpace back end



Social media/Sharing buttonsSocial media sharing buttonsDevsShould haveFrontS

Blacklight

DSpace front end custom




Links/buttons for sharing work via social media (Twitter, Facebook/LinkedIn)
Share via email button or function
DevsShould have FrontS

Blacklight

DSpace front end custom





New human-readable URLCustomizable URLGabe/ChinMust haveBackSDSpace back end

Yes it's implementable.

The Services group must decide on the URL

Jira Legacy
serverSystem JIRA
serverId72190e5c-ce35-3f39-b915-64292d694deb
keyDSPAC-81

Thumbnails next to recently added

Devs

Could haveFrontS

Blacklight

DSpace front end custom

DSpace front end standard


Done through DSpace this requires customization of the DSpace theme.  

It's unclear how thumbnails would be generated in a blacklight skin



ADA note integrated into interface
DevsMust haveFrontS

Blacklight

DSpace front end custom

DSpace front end standard


Text in footer 

ORCID integration- front end

Green ORCID button linking back to author's ORCID profile, as in DukeSpace

Devs

Must have/should haveFrontS

Blacklight

DSpace front end custom



DSPAC-65- ORCID strategyIN PROGRESS

Cambridge: https://www.repository.cam.ac.uk/handle/1810/266430

Duke: https://dukespace.lib.duke.edu/dspace/handle/10161/8875

DSpace orcid documentation: https://wiki.duraspace.org/display/DSDOC6x/ORCID+Integration

Thread on v6.2 compatibility and 6.3 errors

https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/dspace-tech/N_azMfWalD8

GG's orcid doc: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ump6tlTrd62nvDoXo4I9GBsSdLs5SeY7k1flP2InYTs/edit

6.3 errors doc: 

https://groups.google.com/forum/#!searchin/dspace-tech/orcid|sort:date/dspace-tech/09qKMO-qTyM/lMAKDz04AAAJ

https://groups.google.com/forum/#!searchin/dspace-tech/orcid|sort:date/dspace-tech/N_azMfWalD8/Kzhwner5GQAJ

Transform language codes (or any metadata value) into full words via display layer the field contains the value 'en' but the interface displays the word 'English'DevsMust haveFrontM

Blacklight

DSpace front end custom

DSpace front end standard


This is doable through the tweaking of the native theme or another theme like Mirage2.  I was unable to find a way to do this other than through the theme

Note that this could be done easily by adding another language field specifically for display, however the metadata group would prefer to avoid this

DSPAC-66- Transform language codes for display TO DO

Thread on the topic: 

http://dspace.2283337.n4.nabble.com/A-way-to-alter-metadata-values-for-display-td4689929.html#a4689930

Thread: https://groups.google.com/forum/#!searchin/dspace-tech/orcid|sort:date/dspace-tech/f_BZETZYXiM/mavRYst_AwAJ

Auto-Generate MIME types



Automatically populate a field with MIME type values based on file extensionDevsShould haveBackMDSpace back end
Last option- contact Texas Uni  DSPAC-75- Auto-generate MIME types TO DO

See convo with Andrea Schweer

Notes from Services Metadata meeting:  This will impact how cumbersome the workflow is for the IR manager.  How cumbersome will depend on the volume of submissions, which is currently unknown.  

SWORD mapping from ProQuestAutomatic ingests of ETDs and associated metadata from ProQuest, plus mapping

Gabe/Chin/Holly

Possibly Devs

Should haveBackMDSpace back end
OngoingDSPAC-60- SWORD Mapping; PQ->DSpaceIN PROGRESS

DSpace METS SIP Profile: https://wiki.duraspace.org/display/DSPACE/DSpaceMETSSIPProfile

Extend embargo functionality 


Items embargoed through the DSpace administrative layer would be either invisible, or would display metadata-onlyGabe/ChinMust have BackMDSpace back end

It can easily be enabled in the submission form.  To auto-apply embargos via imported ProQuest metadata we need to provide an exact lift date.  Two additional back-end fields must be implemented, embargo.field.terms and embargo.field.lift.  

Note that there may be an exact date in the regular metadata from proquest ETD admin

DSPAC-63- Extending embargo functionality- feasibility IN PROGRESS

Embargo documentation https://wiki.duraspace.org/display/DSDOC6x/DSpace+6.x+Documentation

Implement a variation on this for 'six month', '1 year', etc.: http://wiki.lib.sun.ac.za/index.php?title=SUNScholar/Embargo_Systems/1.8.X

Embargo setter javascript: https://github.com/DSpace/DSpace/blob/master/dspace-api/src/main/java/org/dspace/embargo/DefaultEmbargoSetter.java


CVs- internal list
Gabe/ChinMust haveBackMDSpace back end

DSPAC-80- Controlled VocabsTO DOhttps://wiki.duraspace.org/display/DSPACE/Authority+Control+of+Metadata+Values
CVs- external lookup (via something like LCSH)This would happen exclusively through DSpace, via out-of-the-box functionalityGabe/ChinCould haveBackMDSpace back end



CVs- ORCIDIntegrate ORCID into back end Gabe/ChinCould have BackMDSpace back end

Should be straightforward

Note:  The Services group's ORCID enhancement depends on this.  



https://wiki.duraspace.org/display/DSDOC6x/ORCID+Integration

Mirage2 theme-implementCustomizable display layer, including homepage, subpage, configurable interface, customizable facets, etc.Gabe/ChinNAFrontSNA

Jira Legacy
serverSystem JIRA
serverId72190e5c-ce35-3f39-b915-64292d694deb
keyDSPAC-67

Meeting Example:  https://atmire.com/preview/browse?type=title

See note on this page, specifically 'Enabling and building the DSpace 5 Mirage 2 theme' for troubleshooting ideas

Thread on error encountered by Chin, with Fix by Tim Donohue

DOI patchFix for 6.x DOI prob

Gabe/Chin

Maybe devs

NABack

S

M

NA


Thread on the issue: 

https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/dspace-tech/EQUlVrif-u8

The old DIM2DataCite.xsl crosswalk: https://github.com/DSpace/DSpace/blob/master/dspace/config/crosswalks/DIM2DataCite.xsl

Patched DIM2DataCite.xsl crosswalk: https://github.com/DSpace/DSpace/pull/2321/commits 

Upgrade to 6.3
Gabe/ChinNABack

M

S

NA

Make a backup plan and implement first.  


Use Meld to find versions of our file

DSPAC-72- Upgrade to 6.3IN PROGRESS

Note: DSpace 7.0 will be released mid 2019

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JBH0A3QwBUk . (see 18:36 for directories to back up... back up a) sql and solr databases.  see 20:30, section on using meld to discover differences.  23:50 for folders to check for changes)

More Issues






See Jira Board

...

Core FunctionalityRequirementsComplications and question: Notes/DecisionsJira TicketsReference Links
DOI generation

DOI agency integrated with DSpace

DSpace, when configured so that DOI generation is integrated, automatically generates a DOI for each item added to the repository.  

    1. Would this be acceptable?   

    2. If not, how would generating DOIs manually look, workflow-wise?

    3. How would we deal with the fact that many articles deposited via our RIM already have DOIs?  The DOIs generated in DSpace would have to be manually deleted, and we'd have to get DOIs imported through Elements into the same field as DOIs generated by DSpace.


Jira Legacy
serverSystem JIRA
serverId72190e5c-ce35-3f39-b915-64292d694deb
keyDSPAC-3

DOI generationManual retrieval and entry of DOIs

How would manual generation of DOIs through a new Libraries CrossRef membership work?  This would be the simplest solution, however would require more manual intervention per-item.  

    1. Would be a cataloger task?

    2. Would this happen through a process integrated into the metadata approval process?  




Subscribing to a DOI Registration agency

We'll need to join a DOI registration service
  1. Crossref -which is difficult to integrate with DSpace and may require dev support for DSpace integration- is cheap ($275 yearly, $1 per DOI).  

  2. DataCite -which integrates easily with DSpace- is, annecdotally at least, far more expensive (7k yearly?!?);  Their pricing is opaque, we’d have to get a quote.


Jira Legacy
serverSystem JIRA
serverId72190e5c-ce35-3f39-b915-64292d694deb
keyDSPAC-37

Jira Legacy
serverSystem JIRA
serverId72190e5c-ce35-3f39-b915-64292d694deb
keyDSPAC-41



DOIs for dataDecide if we want DOIs for data
  1. It’s a complicated question… look at the Australian National Data Services guidelines

    1. Would we have to follow something like this?  

    1. ANDS guide

    2. Decision tree




...

Core FunctionalityRequirementsComplications and question: Notes/DecisionsJira TicketsReference Links
Elements Deposit interface- customize statements

Guidance text- we'll need to provide a statement

Institutional Advice- we'll need to provide a statement



Jira Legacy
serverSystem JIRA
serverId72190e5c-ce35-3f39-b915-64292d694deb
keyDSPAC-32
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1p57lEx70eWyYMhd_EIAias7f9-H-U7Ecb8pKpLnsJ-E/edit

DSpace- licenses

Customize license for Elements→DSpace submission workflow

We may not have to use this... the interface a faculty submitter will have to use is the Elements interface


DSpace- licensesCustomize license/advisory text for Direct Submission→DSpace  workflow



ADA policiesDetermine what they are and how they affect our configurationA text readable layer is required on all digital objects.  This means that the ETD PDFs will have to be OCRed, as well as PDFs ingested via Elements.  


Workflow considerations

Core FunctionalityRequirementsComplications and question: Notes/DecisionsJira TicketsReference Links
Implementation of 'deposit' button in Elements

a deposit embedded in the Elements interface, usable by both library staff and faculty users of our RIMS 

It must be enabled universally.  Is this a problem?  

This functionality cannot be limited only to certain classes of user.  

The crosswalk allows us to move items deposited from Elements→DSpace to specific dspace collections based on their 'publication type' status in elements.  This could be one solution.  




Library mediated deposits from Elements→DSpace

We've discussed having the library deposit from Elements to DSpace on faculty member's behalf.  

One complication is that Elements indexes articles hosted in other systems, but does not ingest copies of articles.  What are the workflow and legal implications of downloading these articles directly from the publication.

Another complication is that many journals allow the deposit of the preprint or accepted version, but not the publisher's version.  How would we obtain one of the permissible versions, which would be unpublished.  




Dark archive?We could set up a DSpace collection shielded from the public that would facilitate the long term preservation of faculty research, while keeping it in accessible due to legal complications

Is this worth it?  

Is this too far in the wrong direction re: open access?




...